Functional safety technical resource
What Is Tolerable Risk?
Tolerable risk is risk that an organization or governing framework is prepared to accept in a defined context while the activity continues under specified controls. It is not zero risk and not one universal numerical limit. In functional safety, approved tolerable-risk criteria help determine whether additional risk reduction is needed and, when a SIF is allocated, what integrity that function must provide.
Technical resource from Mangan Safety Instrumented Systems (Mangan SIS)
How Tolerable Risk Is Established
Risk criteria may be set by law, regulators, corporate policy, industry practice, project governance, or a combination of these sources. They can address individual risk, societal risk, environmental harm, asset loss, or other endpoints, and may use qualitative, semi-quantitative, or quantitative methods. The responsible organization should approve the criteria before they are applied to scenarios. Criteria must define consequence categories, frequency measures, exposed populations, time basis, treatment of uncertainty, aggregation rules, and any conditions attached to acceptance. Copying a number from another facility or jurisdiction can create a misleading result.
Tolerable, Broadly Acceptable, and Unacceptable Risk
Some frameworks distinguish an unacceptable region, a middle region where risk is tolerable only when further reduction obligations are satisfied, and a broadly acceptable region where additional effort may be limited. These labels are not interchangeable. Tolerable does not mean desirable, negligible, permanently approved, or exempt from good practice. HSE's Tolerability of Risk framework informs its regulatory decision-making in Great Britain, but HSE states that the framework is not guidance for dutyholders. Organizations using similar bands should define their own approved basis and legal context.
How Tolerable Risk Supports SIL Determination
A hazard and risk assessment estimates or categorizes risk for a defined scenario, accounts for existing safeguards under the selected method, and compares the result with approved criteria. The gap between the evaluated risk and the target informs the additional risk reduction required. If a SIF is selected to provide part of that reduction, the team assigns functional requirements and a SIL target. IEC 61511-3 illustrates methods for this work but does not specify the SIL for a particular application or supply a universal tolerable-risk value.
Uncertainty, Change, and Continued Tolerability
Risk estimates depend on scenario completeness, consequence models, initiating-event data, human factors, safeguard independence, conditional modifiers, and operating assumptions. Results close to a decision boundary deserve particular attention to uncertainty and sensitivity. Acceptance should also be revisited after process changes, new incident information, safeguard degradation, demand experience, altered occupancy, or revised legal and owner criteria. Mangan SIS recommends recording criteria ownership, assumptions, credited safeguards, uncertainty, action closure, and revalidation triggers rather than preserving only the final risk rank or SIL.
Mangan SIS project context
Apply Tolerable Risk to documented SIS decisions
Tolerable-risk criteria support hazard-study prioritization, LOPA, quantitative risk analysis, SIF allocation, and decisions about further safeguards. The glossary definition is intentionally distinct from Mangan's project services, which apply approved criteria to the facility's actual scenarios and evidence.
Sources and scope
Use the source type that fits the decision
Standards
IEC 61511-3:2016 illustrates hazard and risk assessment and SIL-determination methods and provides a framework for establishing required safety integrity. It explicitly does not specify the SIL required for particular applications, leaving risk criteria and decisions to the responsible parties.
Guidance
HSE's Tolerability of Risk framework distinguishes regulatory decision regions in Great Britain. HSE states that R2P2 is not guidance for dutyholders, so its numerical or conceptual boundaries should not be treated as universal facility criteria without an approved and jurisdictionally appropriate basis.
Regulation
OSHA 29 CFR 1910.119 requires covered employers to identify, evaluate, and control process hazards, but it does not prescribe one numerical tolerable-risk threshold or mandate the HSE framework. Applicable U.S. duties, RAGAGEP, and owner criteria should remain clearly distinguished.
Mangan recommendation
Mangan SIS recommends approving risk criteria before scenario evaluation, defining every measure and endpoint, documenting uncertainty and safeguard credit, and requiring reassessment when process conditions, evidence, or governing criteria change.
Primary references
- IEC 61511-3:2016 – required SIL determination guidance (International standard guidance)
- HSE – Tolerability of Risk regulatory framework (UK regulator policy)
- OSHA 29 CFR 1910.119 – Process Safety Management (U.S. regulation)
Common questions
Clarifying Tolerable Risk
Does tolerable risk mean a process is safe?
No. It means the evaluated risk is accepted within a defined framework and conditions. Residual risk remains, controls must be maintained, and changes or new evidence can require reassessment.
Is there one universal tolerable-risk number?
No. Criteria depend on jurisdiction, organization, endpoint, exposed population, method, and context. The basis should be approved and documented before it is used to determine risk reduction.
How does tolerable risk affect a SIL target?
The difference between evaluated scenario risk and the approved target helps establish required additional risk reduction. If a SIF supplies part of that reduction, its functional requirements and SIL target are then specified and verified.
Need a defensible risk criterion?
Connect consequence, frequency, uncertainty, safeguards, and SIF targets to an approved basis.
Downloadable term reference
Download: Tolerable Risk – Functional Safety Glossary PDF
Save or share this term-specific reference, including the answer-first definition, engineering review considerations, and primary-source references.